Sunday 14 July 2013

Book Review: The Battle of Mons Aelian by Francis Hagan




This is a free* short story I picked up the other day on Amazon. It is an account of a fictional 5th Century Roman battle in North Africa. It is written from the point of view of a battlefield archaeologist as he discovers the site and pieces together the surviving evidence to try to work out what happened 1500 years before. I thought the authors choice to write from this perspective was an interesting one and made the novel itself more interesting that it may otherwise of been.

The battle described is something of a small one but would make for an interesting wargames scenario however I'm not 100% sure of the authenticity of the tactics the author uses for the Roman legion so I would recommend checking that out first before using it as a scenario. Most of my reading on the Romans has focused on the Republic and early Empire so I'd need to re-read a few of my other books on the later Empire to be sure if I was to recreate this scenario.

There were a few grammatical and spelling errors but as they aren't my strong points either I can't really complain too much. Overall its an interesting little story but wouldn't be something I'd actually want to pay for.

Full Title: The Battle of Mons Aelian
Author: Francis Hagan
Pages: roughly 21 (7,000 words)
Publisher: Francis Hagan (9 July 2013)
Language: English
Price: Free (Kindle)

*I can't find any evidence that it's been anything but free.

- Posted using BlogPress

Saturday 13 July 2013

Book Review: Opening Moves (Red Gambit Series Book 1)





I finished reading this novel earlier today and I have to say this is one of the best Alternative History I've read - I was hooked from page 1. It has a well written and researched plot complete with a large cast of believable characters (though admittedly some don't last very long once the shells start landing!). It isn't a short book (some 800 pages) but is well worth reading.

The book is written around a fictional Soviet attack on her former Western Allies in August 1945 and follows the actions of various officers and the men under their command. These characters come from a wide range of Nations and backgrounds which are further supported by an accompanying biography that is available as a separate book (which I've not had chance to read yet as I didn't want to accidentally learn something that would spoil the narrative for me).

I'm sure that there will be people out there who will disagree with the authors representations of the various weapons and tactics. However I didn't come across anything that I would strongly disagree with or thought implausible. The descriptions of combat were in line with descriptions the various personal and unit histories that I have read over the years - in short they are very realistic, bloody and brutal so definitely not for the faint hearted!

The author doesn't skirt away from the atrocities of war so be warned that this book does contain such things. Although this sort of thing isn't what we would necessarily want to read about it is unfortunately a feature of war throughout the ages and shouldn't be glossed over or forgotten.

The book in its self is broken in to multiple time line based sections and you do jump about from place to place but this doesn't affect the flow of the narrative. It also allows the author to give you different viewpoints of the same event without having to recap on what's happened or break the flow of the narrative.

Also included at the appropriate points in the narrative are plenty of maps detailing the events in the text, unfortunately with the Kindle version these maps aren't brilliant once you zoom in but are still understandable. I believe that versions of these maps are available from the authors website.

From a wargamers point of view there are a considerable amount of detailed scenarios that could be easily extracted from the text. As most of the weapons used are those available to late war armies, assembling forces suitable for recreating the events of the book wouldn't be difficult at all. There are one or two weapons that appear that didn't see service but they can easily be converted or already exist as models in various scales (e.g. IS-3 tanks). As I understand it more of this type of equipment appears in the later parts of the series which may possibly make recreating scenarios from the later books more of a challenge.

I would thoroughly recommend this book and I look forward to reading the next 5 books (of which 2 (Breakthrough and Stalemate) have already been published).

Full Title: Opening Moves - The first book in the Red Gambit Series: 1
Author: Colin Gee
Paperback: 802 pages
Publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform (31 Dec 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1468145134
ISBN-13: 978-1468145137
Price: £13.99 ("real" book) or £3.38 (Kindle)

- Posted using BlogPress

Sunday 7 July 2013

Book Review: German Defensive Batteries and Gun Emplacements




I received this A4 sized 48 page booklet on the German Atlantic Wall Defences facing the Normandy invasion in yesterdays post. Consisting mostly of black and white photographs this introduction to these fortifications is quite an easy read, though it is worth taking some time over the photos. Note that this book only covers the artillery gun emplacements in the invasion area, it does not cover all of the fortifications in Normandy and it doesn't go in to detail about things such as trenches, shelters or minefields surrounding any of the fortifications.

The information given for each of the batteries varies somewhat, for some of them you get a set of plans of individual bunkers (some but not all of these are dimensioned, though the scale isn't stated but could easily be worked out) then for others you'll not get anything much at all other than a brief description, some details of what happened to the battery and a few photographs.

I found some of the descriptions of the batteries quite interesting and I did learn some new information. There is also a handy list at the back of the emplacements, the unit manning them and what guns they had. As I'm working on a battery that's based on the Longues-sur-Mer Battery this booklet was a helpful resource when combined with other information - more on this battery model later....

In summary I'd say that the book is worth buying but if you want a detailed guide to any particular battery you would need a bigger more detailed book or perhaps the guide book for one of these sites.

Full Title: German Defensive Batteries and Gun Emplacements on the Normandy Beaches Invasion: D-Day June 6 1944
Authors: Karl-Heinz Schmeelke & Michael Schmeelke
Publisher: Schiffer Military/Aviation History (1995)
Language: English
ISBN: 0-88740-755-2
Price: £7.93 ("real" book - on Amazon.co.uk)

- Posted using BlogPress